Community Shield: Manchester United vs Wigan Athletic – Player Ratings

Manchester United v Wigan Athletic - FA Community Shield

Manchester United

David de Gea: 6

Had basically nothing to do all game in any department, so almost impossible to gauge his performance. Seemed to be correctly positioned and comfortable on the ball, as always.

Rafael: 7

Looked excellent as ever going forward until injury forced him off early, at which point United visibly lost some drive and purpose.

Nemanja Vidic:8

Snuffed out most of the dangers before they became a problem, and showed why he is still a key player for United. Keeping fit all season would be a huge boost to United’s chances.

Phil Jones: 4

Failed to be of use when switched to right-back, costing United much of their forward impetus and misplacing some simple passes with alarming regularity. Cause for concern.

Chris Smalling: 5

Had little to do, but was caught under the high ball and beaten by James McClean too easily for what ought to have been a Wigan equaliser.

Patrice Evra: 7

As consistent as ever from Evra, who showed plenty of penetration getting forward with his runs, even if his final ball was lacklustre at times. A fine cross for the opener, too.

Michael Carrick: 6

Was asked very little by Wigan as they completely failed to put any pressure on him. Kept things ticking over but did nothing spectacular.

Tom Cleverley: 4

Provided little in the way of control, drive, or composure, and woefully mishit one excellent chance. If United do spend on the midfield this season then his time at the club must be called into question if he cannot improve.

Ryan Giggs: 6

Did OK with his control and passing, but faded as the game went on, as thirty-nine year olds are bound to.

Wilfried Zaha: 6

Should probably have done better against an opponent of such inferiority as Stephen Crainey, and although he was lively, he’s shown much better form in pre-season.

Danny Welbeck: 8 (Man of the Match)

Ran the show in United’s attack, involved in almost every decent passage of play shown by the Reds. He can be inconsistent from one minute to the next with his touch and passing, but at times his speed of thought and invention is remarkable, as it frequently was today.

Robin van Persie: 8

One magnificent header and a lucky deflection gave him a brace to start the season off, but his all-round play was typically excellent too. Linked up well with Danny Welbeck and Wilfried Zaha, which is highly promising.

Antonio Valencia: 6

Looked reasonably lively and energetic after coming on, but struggled to replicate the delivery that was once so key down United’s right flank.

Anderson: 6

Showed better ideas than Cleverley, but could not live up to them with the execution and failed to really impose himself in the brief cameo he made.


Wigan Athletic

Scott Carson: 6

Beaten by an unchallenged Robin van Persie for United’s opener but made a super save from Danny Welbeck eight minutes before half time to keep his team in it.

Emmerson Boyce: 5

Good header back across a packed United box from a free-kick. Among several players rooted to the spot as Van Persie headed in unmarked for his first goal.

James Perch: 5

Unlucky to deflect Robin van Persie’s effort into his own net just before the hour. Decent enough performance alongside Boyce but, like Boyce, caught-ball-watching for the first goal.

Leon Barnett: 5

Unlucky not to direct Boyce’s header across goal into the United net just before half time. A difficult afternoon trying to cope with United’s movement.

Stephen Crainey: 5

Poor touch on a rare, 20th-minute, Wigan attack to ultimately lose possession. Needed the help of James McClean to cope with Zaha marauding forward.

James McCarthy: 5

Not a performance to match his towering reputation. Muted by United’s class and efficiency. No real impact on the Reds’ backline.

Ben Watson: 6

The match winner against the other Manchester club back in May but not such a happy time this afternoon. Plenty of effort and endeavour but no real penetration against a United team in second gear. Replaced on the hour by Chris McCann.

James McArthur: 4

Booked just after half time. But did little of note before that as his side were outclassed by the Premier League champions

Shaun Maloney: 6

A battling, industrious – and at times skilfull – performance in midfield without ever really hurting United. Could yet find himself up against United again this season with three weeks of the window left.

Grant Holt: 5

Good contest between the former Norwich striker and Nemanja Vidic but ultimately the United man came out on top with Wigan unable to provide good enough service.

James McClean: 6

Went for power with his 35th-minute ball into Grant Holt at the near post when a simple cushioned effort would have given his team-mate a great chance. Grew into the game.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: